Best Thrift Stores in Lancaster, PA [Ranked by Locals]

The Lanc Local team analyzed over 8,400 local reviews and metrics to find the best thrift stores Lancaster has to offer.

Enjoy!

Top thrift stores in the Lancaster, PA area

LOCALS’ CHOICE

The Bees’ Knees Family Thrift & Collectibles, LLC

5

/5 rating

(

47

reviews)

Intercourse
More Information

LOCALS’ CHOICE

Lancaster Creative Reuse

4.8

/5 rating

(

213

reviews)

Lancaster
More Information

LOCALS’ CHOICE

Revive Thrift Store

4.9

/5 rating

(

32

reviews)

Ephrata
More Information

Full list of thrift stores in Lancaster, PA

A Passage In Time

4.1

/5 rating

(

9

reviews)

Lancaster
More Information

Goodwill Store & Donation Center – Willow Street

4

/5 rating

(

170

reviews)

Willow Street
More Information

Main Street Closet

4.5

/5 rating

(

122

reviews)

Willow Street
More Information

Basura

4.6

/5 rating

(

36

reviews)

Lancaster
More Information

Columbia Re-Uzit Shop

4.4

/5 rating

(

91

reviews)

Columbia
More Information
CommunityAid

CommunityAid

4.4

/5 rating

(

728

reviews)

Lancaster
More Information

Matthew 25 Thrift Shop

4.6

/5 rating

(

67

reviews)

Lititz
More Information

Mount Joy Gift & Thrift

4.7

/5 rating

(

134

reviews)

Mount Joy
More Information

Jubilee Ministries

4.5

/5 rating

(

168

reviews)

Manheim
More Information

Goodwill Store & Donation Center – Elizabethtown

3.9

/5 rating

(

132

reviews)

Elizabethtown
More Information

Nearly-Nu Thrift Shop

3.8

/5 rating

(

24

reviews)

Manheim
More Information

Frugal Finds LLC

4.5

/5 rating

(

41

reviews)

Elizabethtown
More Information

The Scarlet Willow

4.6

/5 rating

(

64

reviews)

Lancaster
More Information

Bird in Hand Re-Uzit

1

/5 rating

(

1

reviews)

Bird in Hand
More Information

Goodwill Store & Donation Center – Lancaster

3.9

/5 rating

(

443

reviews)

Lancaster
More Information

Re-Uzit Shop of New Holland

4.5

/5 rating

(

492

reviews)

New Holland
More Information

Freedom Thrift on 30 Secondhand Store

4.3

/5 rating

(

7

reviews)

Ronks
More Information

Welcome Home Thrift & More

4.6

/5 rating

(

18

reviews)

Adamstown
More Information

ReUzit on State: An MCC Thrift Store

4.5

/5 rating

(

395

reviews)

Ephrata
More Information

Goodwill Store & Donation Center – Ephrata

3.9

/5 rating

(

268

reviews)

Ephrata
More Information

Uncle Funky’s Thrift Shop

3.9

/5 rating

(

79

reviews)

Denver
More Information

Once Upon A Child Lancaster

3.4

/5 rating

(

48

reviews)

Lancaster
More Information

Harmony’s Treasures

4.5

/5 rating

(

2

reviews)

Ephrata
More Information

Morgantown ReUzit Shoppe

4.4

/5 rating

(

106

reviews)

Morgantown
More Information

New Hope Community Closet

4.6

/5 rating

(

54

reviews)

Quarryville
More Information

Jazzy Julie’s Past to Present

5

/5 rating

(

1

reviews)

New Holland
More Information

Leola Thrift Shoppe

4.3

/5 rating

(

54

reviews)

Leola
More Information

Share & Care Shop

4

/5 rating

(

4

reviews)

New Holland
More Information

Country Gift & Thrift Shoppe

4.7

/5 rating

(

187

reviews)

Gap
More Information

Freedom Thrift

4.8

/5 rating

(

92

reviews)

New Holland
More Information

Lancaster Habitat for Humanity ReStore

4.4

/5 rating

(

393

reviews)

Lancaster
More Information

Revive Thrift Store

4.9

/5 rating

(

32

reviews)

Ephrata
More Information

BUiLDiNG CHARACTER

4.7

/5 rating

(

672

reviews)

Lancaster
More Information

Lancaster Creative Reuse

4.8

/5 rating

(

213

reviews)

Lancaster
More Information

Think Big Think Small We Have It All

4.9

/5 rating

(

14

reviews)

Columbia
More Information

Take Two & More, LLC

5

/5 rating

(

11

reviews)

Leola
More Information

Explore the Best of Lancaster, PA [Ranked by Locals]