Best Insurance Agencies in Lancaster, PA [Ranked by Locals]

Written by: RJ Weaver (Local Guide)

Analyzed, reviewed & edited by: Lanc Local staff

Last Updated:

Lanc Local analyzed 6,915

local customer reviews and metrics to find the best Insurance Agencies

Lancaster

has to offer.

Why trust Lanc Local?
  • These rankings are curated by our team of Lancaster County locals -- real people, not an algorithm, not AI.
  • We evaluate all categories using unbiased criteria, including reviews, number of reviews, average rating, location, and aggregated data vs. similar businesses.
  • Learn more about Lanc Local & our ranking methodology.

Best Insurance Agencies

Near Lancaster, PA

We ranked the following

Insurance Agencies

according their Lanc Local rating. The Lanc Local rating is a score given by our team based on customer reviews, location, customer ratings, and aggregated data vs. similar businesses in the area.

Insurance Agencies in Lancaster: Sean Kelleher - State Farm Insurance Agent

Sean Kelleher – State Farm Insurance Agent

5

★★★★★

(408 Reviews)

Lanc Local Rating: 88.33
Lancaster
Insurance Agencies in Lancaster: HomeSale Insurance Services

HomeSale Insurance Services

5

★★★★★

(350 Reviews)

Lanc Local Rating: 87.98
Lancaster
Insurance Agencies in Manheim: Baron Insurance Group

Baron Insurance Group

5

★★★★★

(251 Reviews)

Lanc Local Rating: 87.34
Manheim
Insurance Agencies in Ephrata: Douple Agency

Douple Agency, Inc.

4.9

★★★★★

(266 Reviews)

Lanc Local Rating: 87.16
Ephrata
Insurance Agencies in Lancaster: Bagnall Shaw Insurance

Bagnall Shaw Insurance

4.7

★★★★★

(345 Reviews)

Lanc Local Rating: 86.89
Lancaster
Insurance Agencies in Lancaster: Forbes Insurance Agency - Erie Insurance

Forbes Insurance Agency – Erie Insurance

5

★★★★★

(173 Reviews)

Lanc Local Rating: 86.79
Lancaster
Insurance Agencies in Lancaster: Susquehanna Insurance

Susquehanna Insurance

4.9

★★★★★

(198 Reviews)

Lanc Local Rating: 86.75
Lancaster
Insurance Agencies in Lititz: Susquehanna Insurance - Erie Insurance

Susquehanna Insurance – Erie Insurance

5

★★★★★

(137 Reviews)

Lanc Local Rating: 86.51
Lititz
Insurance Agencies in Strasburg: Valerie Stocker - State Farm Insurance Agent

Valerie Stocker – State Farm Insurance Agent

5

★★★★★

(136 Reviews)

Lanc Local Rating: 86.5
Strasburg
Insurance Agencies in Manheim: Next Steps Insurance

Next Steps Insurance

5

★★★★★

(123 Reviews)

Lanc Local Rating: 86.4
Manheim

We ranked the following

Insurance Agencies

by popularity -- using volume & frequency of reviews as reflection of how often these places are chosen.

Insurance Agencies in Lancaster: Sean Kelleher - State Farm Insurance Agent

Sean Kelleher – State Farm Insurance Agent

5

★★★★★

(408 Reviews)

Lanc Local Rating: 88.33
Lancaster
Insurance Agencies in Lancaster: HomeSale Insurance Services

HomeSale Insurance Services

5

★★★★★

(350 Reviews)

Lanc Local Rating: 87.98
Lancaster
Insurance Agencies in Lancaster: Bagnall Shaw Insurance

Bagnall Shaw Insurance

4.7

★★★★★

(345 Reviews)

Lanc Local Rating: 86.89
Lancaster
Insurance Agencies in New Holland: Goodville Mutual Casualty Company

Goodville Mutual Casualty Company

4.1

★★★★★

(337 Reviews)

Lanc Local Rating: 84.78
New Holland
Insurance Agencies in Marietta: Donegal Insurance Group

Donegal Insurance Group

3

★★★★★

(295 Reviews)

Lanc Local Rating: 81.43
Marietta
Insurance Agencies in Ephrata: Douple Agency

Douple Agency, Inc.

4.9

★★★★★

(266 Reviews)

Lanc Local Rating: 87.16
Ephrata
Insurance Agencies in Manheim: Baron Insurance Group

Baron Insurance Group

5

★★★★★

(251 Reviews)

Lanc Local Rating: 87.34
Manheim
Insurance Agencies in Lancaster: Susquehanna Insurance

Susquehanna Insurance

4.9

★★★★★

(198 Reviews)

Lanc Local Rating: 86.75
Lancaster
Insurance Agencies in Lancaster: Forbes Insurance Agency - Erie Insurance

Forbes Insurance Agency – Erie Insurance

5

★★★★★

(173 Reviews)

Lanc Local Rating: 86.79
Lancaster
Insurance Agencies in Elizabethtown: KMA Insurance Group

KMA Insurance Group

4.8

★★★★★

(167 Reviews)

Lanc Local Rating: 86.36
Elizabethtown

We ranked the following

Insurance Agencies

by average customer rating. We only considered places with over 50 reviews to ensure a fair and reliable sample size.

Insurance Agencies in Lancaster: Sean Kelleher - State Farm Insurance Agent

Sean Kelleher – State Farm Insurance Agent

5

★★★★★

(408 Reviews)

Lanc Local Rating: 88.33
Lancaster
Insurance Agencies in Lancaster: HomeSale Insurance Services

HomeSale Insurance Services

5

★★★★★

(350 Reviews)

Lanc Local Rating: 87.98
Lancaster
Insurance Agencies in Manheim: Baron Insurance Group

Baron Insurance Group

5

★★★★★

(251 Reviews)

Lanc Local Rating: 87.34
Manheim
Insurance Agencies in Lancaster: Forbes Insurance Agency - Erie Insurance

Forbes Insurance Agency – Erie Insurance

5

★★★★★

(173 Reviews)

Lanc Local Rating: 86.79
Lancaster
Insurance Agencies in Lititz: Susquehanna Insurance - Erie Insurance

Susquehanna Insurance – Erie Insurance

5

★★★★★

(137 Reviews)

Lanc Local Rating: 86.51
Lititz
Insurance Agencies in Strasburg: Valerie Stocker - State Farm Insurance Agent

Valerie Stocker – State Farm Insurance Agent

5

★★★★★

(136 Reviews)

Lanc Local Rating: 86.5
Strasburg
Insurance Agencies in Manheim: Next Steps Insurance

Next Steps Insurance

5

★★★★★

(123 Reviews)

Lanc Local Rating: 86.4
Manheim
Insurance Agencies in Lancaster: Eagle One Insurance Agency

Eagle One Insurance Agency

5

★★★★★

(115 Reviews)

Lanc Local Rating: 86.34
Lancaster
Insurance Agencies in Lancaster: Red Rose Insurance

Red Rose Insurance

5

★★★★★

(115 Reviews)

Lanc Local Rating: 86.34
Lancaster
Insurance Agencies in Akron: DeverCare Insurance Group

DeverCare Insurance Group

5

★★★★★

(61 Reviews)

Lanc Local Rating: 85.9
Akron

Discover Lancaster County's hidden gems with this curated list of

Insurance Agencies

with 50 or fewer reviews, but high ratings.

Insurance Agencies in Lancaster: The 2 B's

The 2 B’s

5

★★★★★

(46 Reviews)

Lanc Local Rating: 85.77
Lancaster
Insurance Agencies in Lancaster: One Stop Services Solution LLC

One Stop Services Solution LLC

5

★★★★★

(43 Reviews)

Lanc Local Rating: 85.74
Lancaster
Insurance Agencies in Lancaster: Aaron Basom - State Farm Insurance Agent

Aaron Basom – State Farm Insurance Agent

5

★★★★★

(40 Reviews)

Lanc Local Rating: 85.72
Lancaster
Insurance Agencies in Lancaster: New Heritage Insurance Agency

New Heritage Insurance Agency

5

★★★★★

(29 Reviews)

Lanc Local Rating: 85.62
Lancaster
Insurance Agencies in Willow Street: Spotts Insurance Group Inc

Spotts Insurance Group Inc

5

★★★★★

(27 Reviews)

Lanc Local Rating: 85.6
Willow Street
Insurance Agencies in Mount Joy: Weaver Insurance Group Inc.

Weaver Insurance Group Inc.

5

★★★★★

(19 Reviews)

Lanc Local Rating: 85.53
Mount Joy
Insurance Agencies in Mount Joy: Tyler Parmer - State Farm Insurance Agent

Tyler Parmer – State Farm Insurance Agent

5

★★★★★

(18 Reviews)

Lanc Local Rating: 85.52
Mount Joy
Insurance Agencies in Ephrata: Myers & Bell Insurance

Myers & Bell Insurance

5

★★★★★

(17 Reviews)

Lanc Local Rating: 85.52
Ephrata
Insurance Agencies in Lancaster: Liberty Mutual Car Insurance

Conestoga Title Insurance Co

5

★★★★★

(17 Reviews)

Lanc Local Rating: 85.52
Lancaster
Insurance Agencies in Lancaster: Goosehead Insurance - Jake Brendle

Goosehead Insurance – Jake Brendle

5

★★★★★

(15 Reviews)

Lanc Local Rating: 85.5
Lancaster

Discover the Best of Lancaster County, PA

Weaver's Mill Covered Bridge: East Earl Covered Bridges

Areas & Towns

Texter Mountain Home: Robesonia Hotels

Best Places to Stay

Top-Rated & Hidden Gem Restaurants

Refreshing Mountain Retreat and Adventure Center: Stevens Retreat Centers

Things to Do [Ranked]