The Lanc Local team analyzed 12,186 local reviews and metrics to find the best cheese shops Willow Street, PA has to offer. We rank businesses according to their Bayesian average rating — to prevent rankings from being overly influenced by businesses with only a few reviews.
Top Cheese Shops
Near Willow Street, PA
Down On The Farm Creamery
4.9
(805 Reviews)
Locals' choice
Featured review:
"An off the road Amish creamery with the most decadent hand made ice cream I've ever had. The views are of the hills and farm are a calming backdrop. The animals, esp the babies make for a fun visit as well. Play area for kids allows parents to relax."...
Strasburg
S. Clyde Weaver, Inc.
4.7
(793 Reviews)
Locals' choice
Featured review:
"The staff was so welcoming and helpful ☺️. Aaron gave us wonderful ideas on pairings. Today was a special event on their cheddar cheese, I left with a full tummy and two full bags of new favorites."...
East Petersburg
Mad Chef Craft Brewing
4.7
(793 Reviews)
Locals' choice
Featured review:
"The staff was so welcoming and helpful ☺️. Aaron gave us wonderful ideas on pairings. Today was a special event on their cheddar cheese, I left with a full tummy and two full bags of new favorites." - Angela P....
East Petersburg
Stauffers of Kissel Fresh Foods
4.6
(1,471 Reviews)
Locals' choice
Featured review:
"Wow the produce, bakery, meats and seafood are phenomenal at the Staffers of Kissel Hill Fresh Market. The prices are actually exceptional compared to the stores that we have in Maryland. The store is clean, bright and very well laid out. The aisles are wide and marked well for easy navigation. The...
Lancaster
S. Clyde Weaver, Inc.
4.6
(1,471 Reviews)
Locals' choice
Featured review:
"Wow the produce, bakery, meats and seafood are phenomenal at the Staffers of Kissel Hill Fresh Market. The prices are actually exceptional compared to the stores that we have in Maryland. The store is clean, bright and very well laid out. The aisles are wide and marked well for easy navigation. Th...
Lancaster
S. Clyde Weaver, Inc.
4.7
(237 Reviews)
Locals' choice
Featured review:
"From out of town and heard about their bacon. Stopped in on a business trip and left work more often than then bacon. I was offered the opportunity to taste several deli meats and their kielbasa. It's definitely the best ham I ever tasted. If you're in the area and like smoked ham this is the place...
Lancaster
Appel Valley Butcher Shop
4.7
(237 Reviews)
Locals' choice
Featured review:
"From out of town and heard about their bacon. Stopped in on a business trip and left work more often than then bacon. I was offered the opportunity to taste several deli meats and their kielbasa. It's definitely the best ham I ever tasted. If you're in the area and like smoked ham this is the plac...
Lancaster
Whole Foods Market
4.4
(1,172 Reviews)
Locals' choice
Featured review:
"Chris at the meat counter is truly exceptional and I hope that the management team will give him a pad on the back and job well done as an executive chef. I really appreciate seeing him do something tonight that I’ve never seen in any other local deli or meat counter, and that was as soon as he c...
Lancaster
Lemon Street Market
4.4
(1,172 Reviews)
Locals' choice
Featured review:
"Chris at the meat counter is truly exceptional and I hope that the management team will give him a pad on the back and job well done as an executive chef. I really appreciate seeing him do something tonight that I’ve never seen in any other local deli or meat counter, and that was as soon as he c...
Lancaster
Myer Springdell Farm Pasture Raised Beef
5
(26 Reviews)
Locals' choice
Featured review:
"I have not eaten everything I bought yet, but love the A2/A2 Organic Raw Paradise Reserve Cheddar Cheese and wild Alaskan Sockeye salmon! Very flavorful! I will definitely be ordering again." - Kathryn S....
Paradise