Best Cookie Shops Near Quarryville, PA [Ranked by Locals]

Written by: RJ Weaver (Local Guide)

Analyzed, reviewed & edited by: Lanc Local staff

Last Updated:

Best Hidden Gem

Old Barn Creamery entrance outside - Holtwood, PA

Old Barn Creamery

Old Barn Creamery is Lanc Local's pick for best hidden gem, due to its scenic, tucked-away location and very positive customer feedback.
Holtwood
Fresh from the farm, hand-dipped ice cream · Homemade baked goods · Fresh dairy products · A2A2 raw milk · Homemade bottled drinks · Cheese · Açaí bowls · Breakfast sandwiches · Soft pretzels · Espresso drinks · Eggs
Great breakfast stop
Beautiful country setting
Very reasonable prices
A true hidden gem of Lancaster County! There’s something for everyone here — ice cream, baked goods, drinks, breakfast sandwiches, etc. Our personal favorite is the homemade oatmeal whoopie pies. Highly recommend this place if you’re in the area or are searching for your next favorite shop.

Lanc Local analyzed 3,344

local customer reviews and metrics to find the best Cookie Shops

Quarryville

has to offer.

Why trust Lanc Local?
  • These rankings are curated by our team of Lancaster County locals -- real people, not an algorithm, not AI.
  • We evaluate all categories using unbiased criteria, including reviews, number of reviews, average rating, location, and aggregated data vs. similar businesses.
  • Learn more about Lanc Local & our ranking methodology.

Top-Rated Overall Cookie Shops

Near Quarryville, PA

The

Cookie Shops

below are listed according to our overall rankings for the

Quarryville

area, starting with the highest-ranked Cookie Shops

first.

Great American Cookies: Lancaster Cookie Shops

Taylor Chip Cookies

4.5

★★★★★

(1,991 Reviews)

Lanc Local Rating: 87.93
Lancaster
Made With Love Not Gluten Bakery: Mount Joy Bakeries

Rise Bake Shoppe and Coffee Bar

4.8

★★★★★

(201 Reviews)

Lanc Local Rating: 86.55
Mount Joy

Best Hidden Gem

Old Barn Creamery entrance outside - Holtwood, PA

Old Barn Creamery

4.8

★★★★★

(75 Reviews)

Lanc Local Rating: 85.84
Holtwood
Fresh from the farm, hand-dipped ice cream · Homemade baked goods · Fresh dairy products · A2A2 raw milk · Homemade bottled drinks · Cheese · Açaí bowls · Breakfast sandwiches · Soft pretzels · Espresso drinks · Eggs
Great breakfast stop
Beautiful country setting
Very reasonable prices
A true hidden gem of Lancaster County! There’s something for everyone here — ice cream, baked goods, drinks, breakfast sandwiches, etc. Our personal favorite is the homemade oatmeal whoopie pies. Highly recommend this place if you’re in the area or are searching for your next favorite shop.
Scratch Bakes: Ephrata Bakeries

Laura The Cookie Lady

4.6

★★★★★

(64 Reviews)

Lanc Local Rating: 85.62
Ephrata

Looking for more rankings?

Click below to view Lancaster County's rankings for Cookie Shops

Best Cookie Shops Near Lancaster, PA [Ranked by Locals]

Discover the Best of Lancaster County, PA

Weaver's Mill Covered Bridge: East Earl Covered Bridges

Areas & Towns

Texter Mountain Home: Robesonia Hotels

Best Places to Stay

Top-Rated & Hidden Gem Restaurants

Refreshing Mountain Retreat and Adventure Center: Stevens Retreat Centers

Things to Do [Ranked]