The Lanc Local team analyzed 2,198 local reviews and metrics to find the best toy stores Lancaster, PA has to offer. We rank businesses according to their Bayesian average rating — to prevent rankings from being overly influenced by businesses with only a few reviews.
Top Toy Stores
Near Lancaster, PA
Outback Toys
4.8
(445 Reviews)
Locals' choice
Featured review:
"Ordered directly from their website since the location is a bit out of the way for me. Got these 4 trucks to add to my growing collection and I'm very pleased with how fast they all came. Within a couple days of ordering, everything was shipped safely and securely and nothing was broken. If you're...
Lititz
Brick Heads
4.9
(235 Reviews)
Locals' choice
Featured review:
"I’ve been coming to Brick Heads since they first opened in 2020. My experience has always been top notch, whether I’m just browsing, or trying to find a certain set / figure / part. I’ve also been able to meet and become friends with a lot of people in the local LEGO community just by being a...
Lancaster
Good’s Store
4.7
(3,702 Reviews)
Locals' choice
Featured review:
"Very well-kept store with a large selection of clothing, shoes, and hardware. Specifically, they have clothes and shoes catered to work as well as casual and formal events. The staff are also friendly to all customers and cater to you if you have any questions. I would recommend this store to anybo...
East Earl
Dave’s Cleanouts and Collectibles
4.8
(178 Reviews)
Locals' choice
Featured review:
"These guys are top-notch and excellent in every way. I sold them a batch of my vintage toys from my childhood and they were knowledgeable, friendly and offered me a fair price. I highly recommend them and felt comfortable parting with my sentimental 80’s toy collection to their capable hands." - ...
Mount Joy
Good’s Store
4.6
(1,392 Reviews)
Locals' choice
Featured review:
"Great store! Just learned that my grandmother shopped there back in the day, my dad is a regular, and I will definitely be keeping the tradition." - Gardening w....
Quarryville
Good’s Store
4.6
(957 Reviews)
Locals' choice
Featured review:
"Really great store clean organized and carries a nice variety of merchandise. I will come in for one thing but somehow end up leaving with many more items.I look forward to the sales and promotions and I am a big fan of their Plus card program. This week they had double points with Plus Card and I...
Ephrata
Books-A-Million
4.4
(588 Reviews)
Locals' choice
Featured review:
"It's great to have an option for buying books that allows you to pick up and page through it. So much of our purchases are online now but I needed to buy a children's book and wanted the option to actually see it before buying and look through it for content. This store has a good variety of select...
Lancaster
Strasburg Train Shop
4.6
(147 Reviews)
Locals' choice
Featured review:
"We at great stop! The train is like stepping back into time and it’s worth the time to experience it. I found several things fascinating but the one thing but the seats intrigued me. The seats flip one way and then another on the way back! Genius and they are original seats. The train is beautif...
Strasburg
Disney Store
4.4
(447 Reviews)
Locals' choice
Featured review:
"I extremely enjoyed my visit. Very polite,and very reasonable prices. Haven't been in a Disney store in a long time I thought they shut them all down but I'm really glad this one is still around very nostalgic and miss it. I had a great experience especially because the parks are so far away" - Mic...
Lancaster
Five Below
4.5
(143 Reviews)
Locals' choice
Featured review:
"I love this store so much to choose from. I have 3 kids birthday party's coming up and I got them some really cool stuff. I got my boys swimming trunks and I also got a few neat things for my tiny back yard." - Elena *....
Lancaster
This list is ranked based on reviews & ratings data. Learn more about how we rank businesses by reading our ranking methodology.
If you'd prefer to see top-rated businesses in Lancaster County by location, take a look at our map.