Best Toy Stores in Lancaster, PA [Ranked by Locals]

The Lanc Local team analyzed over 2,100 local reviews and metrics to find the best toy stores Lancaster, PA has to offer.

Enjoy!

Top toy stores in the Lancaster, PA area

LOCALS’ CHOICE

Toy Stores in Lititz: Outback Toys

Outback Toys

4.8

/5 rating

(

445

reviews)

“Ordered directly from their website since the location is a bit out of the way for me. Got these 4 trucks to add to my growing collection and I’m very pleased with how fast they all came. Within a c…
Lititz

LOCALS’ CHOICE

Toy Stores in Reinholds: The Little Brick Gallery

The Little Brick Gallery

4.9

/5 rating

(

17

reviews)

“Very cool store ! The owner was really nice ! I will definitely be back with my husband!” – Diana S….
Reinholds

LOCALS’ CHOICE

Toy Stores in Lancaster: Brick Heads

Brick Heads

4.9

/5 rating

(

235

reviews)

“I’ve been coming to Brick Heads since they first opened in 2020. My experience has always been top notch, whether I’m just browsing, or trying to find a certain set / figure / part. I’ve also b…
Lancaster

Full list of toy stores in the Lancaster, PA area

Toy Stores in Lancaster: Lititz sensory play lab

Lititz sensory play lab

0

/5 rating

(

0

reviews)

Lancaster
Toy Stores in Mount Joy: Dave's Cleanouts and Collectibles

Dave’s Cleanouts and Collectibles

4.8

/5 rating

(

178

reviews)

Mount Joy
Toy Stores in Reinholds: The Little Brick Gallery

The Little Brick Gallery

4.9

/5 rating

(

17

reviews)

Reinholds
Toy Stores in Lititz: Outback Toys

Outback Toys

4.8

/5 rating

(

445

reviews)

Lititz
Toy Stores in Lititz: Passionate Crafters

Passionate Crafters

5

/5 rating

(

2

reviews)

Lititz
Toy Stores in East Petersburg: Serial Resin Company

Serial Resin Company

5

/5 rating

(

4

reviews)

East Petersburg
Notary Services in Lancaster: Clip Clop Toys

Clip Clop Toys

5

/5 rating

(

1

reviews)

Lancaster
Toy Stores in Elizabethtown: The Tatted Toy Guys

The Tatted Toy Guys

4.8

/5 rating

(

77

reviews)

Elizabethtown
Toy Stores in Strasburg: Strasburg Train Shop

Strasburg Train Shop

4.6

/5 rating

(

147

reviews)

Strasburg
Toy Stores in Columbia: RetroSplat!

RetroSplat!

4.6

/5 rating

(

23

reviews)

Columbia
Toy Stores in Lancaster: Disney Store

Disney Store

4.4

/5 rating

(

434

reviews)

Lancaster
Toy Stores in East Earl: WEAVERLAND VALLEY BOARDS

WEAVERLAND VALLEY BOARDS

4.5

/5 rating

(

6

reviews)

East Earl
Toy Stores in Lancaster: Build-A-Bear Workshop

Build-A-Bear Workshop

4.4

/5 rating

(

276

reviews)

Lancaster
Toy Stores in Ronks: National Toy Train Museum

National Toy Train Museum

4.6

/5 rating

(

222

reviews)

Ronks
Toy Stores in Lancaster: Lapp's Toys

Lapp’s Toys

4.6

/5 rating

(

76

reviews)

Lancaster
Toy Stores in Lancaster: Brick Heads

Brick Heads

4.9

/5 rating

(

235

reviews)

Lancaster
Toy Stores in Lancaster: Go! Calendars

Go! Calendars, Toys & Games

3.8

/5 rating

(

55

reviews)

Lancaster

Explore the Best of Lancaster, PA [Ranked by Locals]