Lanc Local analyzed over 800 restaurants in the Lancaster area. Our goal was to find the best places to eat out in the county.
We considered many factors, such as each restaurant’s reputation among locals, food quality, and staff friendliness. We also looked at price, speed of service, drink selection, ease of ordering, wait times, menu variety, freshness of ingredients, portion sizes, etc.
The results below are a rundown of our favorite restaurants, based on this analysis.
Bon appétit!
Old Barn Creamery & Bakery
157 Martic Heights Dr, Holtwood, PA 17532
Old Barn Creamery serves made-to-order breakfast sandwiches daily from 6 a.m. to 10:30 a.m. Options include bacon, ham, or sausage, served on a wrap or potato roll with cheese and plenty of eggs.
The creamery is also known for seasonal specialties. Strawberry pies appear in the spring, pumpkin treats in the fall, gingersnap ice cream in winter, and Christmas cookies in December.
Orders can be placed by phone, and the shop frequently provides baked goods for events, such as their popular homemade whoopie pies for weddings.
Three reasons we chose Old Barn Creamery & Bakery:
- One of the best breakfast sandwiches you’ll find in Lancaster County
- Reasonable pricing
- Scenic, back road Lancaster County experience
Red Chili Indian and Nepali Food
626 W Orange St, Lancaster, PA 17603
Three reasons we chose Red Chili Indian and Nepali Food:
- Authentic Indian and Nepali food
- Popular chicken momo and chili chicken dishes
- Good prices and great value
Eastern Palace
2206 Columbia Ave, Lancaster, PA 17603
Three reasons we chose Eastern Palace:
- Delicious Thai and Burmese food
- Kind and attentive staff
- Fresh and flavorful dishes
Brazilian Table
26 E Main St, Lititz, PA 17543
Three reasons we chose Brazilian Table:
- Fresh, delicious, and authentic Brazilian food
- A welcoming atmosphere and great service
- A great variety of lunch and dinner options
Genki sushi and grill
1565 Manheim Pike, Lancaster, PA 17601
Three reasons we chose Genki sushi and grill:
- Some of the best sushi and rolls in Lancaster
- A convenient location
- A calm and pleasant dining atmosphere
Norbu Lancaster
38 N Christian St, Lancaster, PA 17602
Three reasons we chose Norbu Lancaster:
- A great variety of authentic and delicious food
- Fast and friendly service
- A good option for vegans and vegetarians
Pho Lotus
1223 Lancaster Rd Suite 107, Manheim, PA 17545
Three reasons we chose Pho Lotus:
- Authentic pho
- A clean and welcoming environment
- Dishes made with fresh ingredients
Koshary Station
4 S Prince St, Millersville, PA 17551
Three reasons we chose Koshary Station:
- Authentic Egyptian food
- Good prices and good portions
- Great koshary and shawarma
Nahual Maya Restaurant
126 N Prince St, Lancaster, PA 17603
Three reasons we chose Nahual Maya Restaurant:
- Delicious pupusas
- A great place for a quick bite
- Fresh food with authentic flavors
The Big 5 African Cuisine
630 N Plum St, Lancaster, PA 17602
Three reasons we chose The Big 5 African Cuisine:
- Authentic African dishes
- Very friendly and welcoming staff
- Great chicken stew and samosas
Lancaster Kosher
1120 Columbia Ave, Lancaster, PA 17603
Three reasons we chose Lancaster Kosher:
- Fresh and delicious kosher food
- Quick service
- Reasonable prices
Oola Bowls Intercourse
3465 Old Philadelphia Pike, Intercourse, PA 17534
Three reasons we chose Oola Bowls Intercourse:
- Excellent bowls with fresh ingredients
- Nice outdoor seating area
- Clean and welcoming environment
Guacamole Specialists
555 Greenfield Rd #114, Lancaster, PA 17601
Three reasons we chose Guacamole Specialists:
- Some of the best guacamole in Lancaster County
- Good prices
- Friendly and helpful staff
Chellas Arepa Kitchen
1830 Hempstead Rd, Lancaster, PA 17601
Three reasons we chose Chellas Arepa Kitchen:
- Authentic arepas
- Award-winning
- Good prices
Freshly Greek
2355 Oregon Pike, Lancaster, PA 17601
Three reasons we chose Freshly Greek:
- Authentic Greek dishes, especially the gyro
- A friendly owner who provides great service
- Consistently delicious and fresh food
Rocky’s BBQ
28 N 3rd St, Columbia, PA 17512
Three reasons we chose Rocky’s BBQ:
- Amazing barbecue with great brisket and ribs
- Their mac and cheese (and other sides) are delicious
- Great prices for what you get
Ninja Ramen
2046 Fruitville Pike, Lancaster, PA 17601, United States
Three reasons we chose Ninja Ramen:
- Delicious and fresh ramen
- Quick and efficient service
- Great atmosphere and ambiance
Hudson Botanical – Café | Catering | Houseplants
133 N Duke St, Lancaster, PA 17602
Three reasons we chose Hudson Botanical – Café | Catering | Houseplants:
- Beautiful atmosphere for a cafe
- Incredible coffee
- Welcoming environment
Miss Calee’s Eats & Treats
329 Main St unit C, Landisville, PA 17538
Three reasons we chose Miss Calee’s Eats & Treats:
- Amazing breakfast menu
- Friendly and quick service
- A great local spot if you’re in the area