Old Barn Creamery & Bakery
A Hidden Gem of Lancaster County
Fresh from the farm, hand-dipped ice cream · Homemade baked goods · Fresh dairy products · A2A2 raw milk · Homemade bottled drinks · Cheese · Açaí bowls · Breakfast sandwiches · Soft pretzels · Espresso drinks · Eggs
Locals’ Choice
Old Barn Creamery & Bakery is one of the top-rated businesses and attractions in Lancaster County, based on ratings, reviews, and location.
Family Owned & Operated
Abe Stoltzfus & his family started Old Barn Creamery & Bakery in the fall of 2022. Their farm, located just across the road, supplies many of the ingredients used in their products.
Scenic Location
Tucked away amidst the rolling countryside the county is known for, Old Barn Creamery & Bakery is one of Lancaster’s best-kept secrets.
Plan Your Visit to Old Barn Creamery & Bakery
Hours
Monday – Friday: 6am-5:30pm
Saturday: 6am-5:30pm
Closed Sunday
Closed Good Friday, Ascension Day, and Other Christian Holidays
Phone Number
Selections
Ice Cream
· Seasonal flavors
· Brownie sundaes
· Hand-dipped or quarters/gallons
Baked Goods
· Homemade donuts
· Whoopie pies, apple dumplings, cookies, pies, etc.
· Soft pretzels (Sat. only)
Dairy Products
· Cheese
· Yogurt
· A2A2 raw milk
· Eggs
Bottled Drinks
· Root beer
· Lemonade
· Kombucha
Breakfast
· Sandwiches
· Wraps
· Coffee
Other Sweet Treats
· Affagotas
· Milkshakes
· Açaí bowls
Frequently Asked Questions
Yes, Old Barn Creamery’s hours are seasonal, with closing times based on the sunset. Opening time remains the same throughout the year at 6 a.m.
Breakfast sandwiches, ice cream, soft pretzels (Sat. only), and seasonal baked goods.
Yes, you can call ahead and order baked goods, breakfast sandwiches, or many other items.
Old Barn Creamery will often complete orders for events, such as whoopie pies for weddings.
Made-to-order breakfast sandwiches are served daily from 6 a.m. to 10:30 a.m. Choose from three meats: bacon, ham, or sausage. Pick your bread: a wrap or a potato roll. Add your choice of cheese, all topped with a generous serving of eggs.
Old Barn Creamery features seasonal flavors across its baked goods, ice cream, pies, and espresso drinks. Favorites include strawberry pies in spring, pumpkin treats in fall, gingersnap ice cream in winter, and Christmas cookies in December.
The Setting
Nestled in the rolling hills of southern Lancaster County, Old Barn Creamery offers stunning farmland views to accompany your treat. Just across the road lies the farm where many of their ingredients are sourced.
Interior Aesthetic
Step inside to find a charming barn-inspired ambiance — wooden walls and ceilings, a wagon wheel chandelier, and hanging lamps that add a warm, rustic touch.
Fresh from the Farm Hand-Dipped Ice Cream
Ice cream doesn’t get more local than this, with ingredients sourced directly from the dairy farm across the road. Choose from over 15 flavors, including seasonal options, and elevate your treat with sprinkles or a waffle cone. Beyond scoops, you can also enjoy root beer floats, milkshakes, sundaes, and banana splits.
Homemade Baked Goods
Enjoy freshly baked goods made right on-site. Whether you’re after a dessert to complement a meal, a sweet indulgence, a savory snack, or simply a loaf of bread, Old Barn Creamery’s extensive selection has something for everyone. Customer favorites include donuts, whoopie pies, cookies, pies, soft pretzels, and apple dumplings.
Local Cheese & Other Dairy Products
Choose from a wide variety of cheeses, yogurt, A2A2 raw milk, and other milk products.
Homemade Bottled Refreshments
Take a sip of Lancaster County with Old Barn Creamery’s handcrafted drinks. From kombucha to root beer, these refreshing beverages are perfect for quenching your thirst and pairing with your favorite treats. Don’t miss a Lancaster favorite during the summer — homemade meadow tea.
Breakfast Sandwiches & Espresso Drinks
Start your day with an incredible breakfast sandwich or wrap made with fresh ingredients, including eggs and cheese straight from the farm. Old Barn Creamery also offers a range of espresso-based creations. Indulge in their creamy espresso-infused milkshakes, enjoy the rich blend of hot espresso poured over velvety ice cream in their affogatos, or savor a classic milkshake with a bold espresso twist. These treats are perfect for coffee lovers seeking something indulgent and refreshing.
